Ready to Stop Smoking? The Pros and Cons of Quitting Cold Turkey

Published Jan 01, 2014

|

Updated Dec 17, 2024

|

Est. reading time: 3 minutes

Key points

  • Quitting smoking cold turkey can save money on cessation products and immediately improve breath, teeth, and smell.
  • Cold turkey quitting can lead to withdrawal symptoms like irritability, depression, insomnia, and physical discomfort.
  • Using smoking cessation aids can increase chances of permanently quitting, but can introduce side effects.
  • Successful quitting strategies include support groups, changing routines, avoiding smokers, and marking progress. FAQs: Q: What are the advantages of quitting smoking cold turkey? A: The benefits include saving money on cessation products, immediate improvements in breath, teeth, and smell, and withdrawal symptoms only lasting around three months. Q: What are the disadvantages of quitting smoking cold turkey? A: The disadvantages can include withdrawal symptoms like irritability, depression, insomnia, and physical discomfort. Q: Can using smoking cessation aids help me quit? A: Yes, using smoking cessation aids can increase your chances of permanently quitting, but they can also introduce side effects and still provide nicotine to your body. Q: What strategies can help me quit smoking successfully? A: Strategies include using support groups, changing your daily routines, avoiding people who smoke, and marking your progress on a calendar. Q: Does quitting smoking cold turkey lead to immediate health improvements? A: Yes, quitting cold turkey can lead to immediate improvements in breath, teeth, and smell, and food will taste better once your body is nicotine free.
  • Despite the challenges, the article emphasizes that with a dedicated plan, smoking aid or support program, quitting smoking is achievable.
Ready to Stop Smoking? The Pros and Cons of Quitting Cold Turkey

The Pros of Cold Turkey Quitting

Research has shown those who quit cold turkey may have a harder time or be unsuccessful but there are some advantages including:

  • You won’t have to spend money on smoking cessation products, which can be expensive.
  • Nicotine patches and gum may seem attractive, but you are still introducing nicotine into your body.
  • You immediately reap the reward of cleaner breath and teeth and are able to gain a stronger sense of smell. Your clothing and locations where you smoke will also smell cleaner.
  • There are many support groups including SmokeFree.gov where members support each other during craving times.
  • Withdrawal symptoms -- if you go cold turkey -- will only last approximately three months.
  • Food will taste better once your body is nicotine free.

The Cons of Quitting Cold Turkey

Along with the advantage of simply quitting nicotine altogether, there are some disadvantages including:

  • Withdrawal symptoms that can include irritability, depression and insomnia. Others may experience physical symptoms such as tremors, headaches and weight gain due to increased appetite.
  • The use of smoking cessation aids has a variety of side effects. Those in pill form are in antidepressant category and many experience unusual dreams, mood changes and even suicidal thoughts. Doctors and pharmacists recommend seeking out an urgent care center if you experience symptoms from these medications.
  • Nicotine patches and gum -- even electronic cigarettes with nicotine are still introducing the substance into your body so you aren’t really nicotine free.
  • People who use stop smoking aids have a higher chance of quitting permanently than those choosing the cold turkey route.

Tips for Quitting Successfully

A nicotine habit is different for everyone. Some of the factors making it harder to quit include:

  • How much one smokes
  • Their routines of smoking -- in the car, after meals, talking on the phone, etc.
  • Mind over matter or willpower is simply easier for some than others.

There are tips to help you quit for good, however, and stop a bad habit that leads to emphysema, cancer and a plethora of other medical conditions. Try some of these:

  • Don’t go it alone, quit with a buddy.
  • Remember that you are not a bad person just because you are addicted to nicotine.
  • Take advantage of support groups online or off.
  • If using stop smoking aids, read all the instructions and follow them to the letter, including starting a daily journal.
  • Change your daily routines.
  • Avoid those who do smoke.
  • Don’t take any nicotine products to places you normally smoke -- work, car, bars or restaurants, etc.
  • Seek the advice of retail clinics where doctors can help you develop a sound cessation plan.
  • Mark your progress on a calendar and reward yourself with something at the end of each week.
  • Eat hard candy or mints and skip food indulgences to stop cravings -- this will help with weight gain.
  • Ask your family for support and remember why they want you to quit smoking -- they want you to be around a long time!

Along with the pros and cons of quitting cold turkey, it’s still possible to quit and while it’s not easy for many, if you stick with a dedicated plan, smoking aid or support program, you will find you are smoke-free in a short period of time.

FAQs

What are some advantages of quitting smoking cold turkey?

Some advantages of quitting smoking cold turkey include saving money on smoking cessation products, immediately experiencing cleaner breath and teeth, gaining a stronger sense of smell, and having cleaner smelling clothes and locations where you smoke. Additionally, withdrawal symptoms will only last approximately three months, and food will taste better once your body is nicotine free.

What are some disadvantages of quitting smoking cold turkey?

Some disadvantages of quitting smoking cold turkey include experiencing withdrawal symptoms such as irritability, depression, insomnia, tremors, headaches, and weight gain due to increased appetite. Also, people who use stop smoking aids have a higher chance of quitting permanently than those choosing the cold turkey route.

Are there any side effects to using smoking cessation aids?

Yes, smoking cessation aids can have a variety of side effects. Those in pill form are in the antidepressant category and many people experience unusual dreams, mood changes, and even suicidal thoughts. It's recommended to seek out an urgent care center if you experience symptoms from these medications.

What factors can make it harder to quit smoking?

Factors that can make it harder to quit smoking include how much one smokes, their routines of smoking (like in the car, after meals, or while talking on the phone), and the fact that willpower is simply easier for some people than others.

What are some tips to help quit smoking for good?

Some tips to help quit smoking for good include quitting with a buddy, taking advantage of support groups, following all instructions if using stop smoking aids, changing your daily routines, avoiding those who do smoke, seeking the advice of retail clinics, marking your progress on a calendar, eating hard candy or mints to stop cravings, and asking your family for support.

Does quitting smoking cold turkey mean you are immediately nicotine free?

Yes, quitting smoking cold turkey means you are immediately nicotine free. However, it's important to note that using nicotine patches, gum, or electronic cigarettes with nicotine still introduces the substance into your body.

Are there support groups available for those who decide to quit smoking cold turkey?

Yes, there are many support groups available for those who decide to quit smoking cold turkey. One such group is SmokeFree.gov, where members support each other during craving times.

How long do withdrawal symptoms typically last when quitting smoking cold turkey?

Withdrawal symptoms typically last approximately three months when quitting smoking cold turkey.

Dr. Rob Rohatsch, MD, is a Board-Certified Emergency Medicine physician and urgent care executive. He earned his MD from Jefferson Medical College, currently serves on multiple boards and is Solv’s Chief Medical Officer.

How we reviewed this article

Medically reviewed

View this article’s sources and history, and read more about Solv’s Content Mission Statement, editorial process, and editorial team.

History

Solv’s team of medical writers and experts review and update our articles when new information becomes available.

  • January 01 2014

    Written by Solv Editorial Team

    Medically reviewed by: Dr. Rob Rohatsch, MD

Solv’s team of medical writers and experts review and update our articles when new information becomes available.

  • January 01 2014

    Written by Solv Editorial Team

    Medically reviewed by: Dr. Rob Rohatsch, MD

Topics in this article

CancerRetail ClinicDepressionUrgent Care

This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using Solv, you accept our use of cookies.