5 Halloween Candy Myths: What's Real and What's Not?

Published Oct 14, 2013

|

Updated Dec 17, 2024

|

Est. reading time: 3 minutes

Key points

  • The myth of strychnine in Sunkist treats was debunked, as the substance was found to be cornstarch.
  • The story of heroin in Halloween candy was a cover-up for a family crime, not a widespread issue.
  • The myth of candy poisoning was debunked, as the child's illness was due to a non-contagious bacteria.
  • While there have been isolated incidents of harmful objects in candy, such as needles in Snickers bars, these are not widespread occurrences.
  • The article emphasizes the importance of examining your child's Halloween candy for safety and seeking medical attention if your child experiences any type of reaction after eating candy.
5 Halloween Candy Myths: What's Real and What's Not?

1. Strychnine in Sunkist Treats

According to the Chicago Tribune, back in 1988 The New York Times reported traces of strychnine were discovered in a box of Sunkist Fun Fruits Dinosaurs. The treats were obtained from a grocery store in New Jersey but once tested by the FDA, the "strychnine" was actually cornstarch.

Unfortunately, Sunkist destroyed 9,400 cases of these fruit treats and declared their image to be tainted. If you see any types of powder or unknown substance on your child's candy, do not let them ingest the candy. If they do and tell you later, head to an urgent care center to be sure your child is okay.

2. Heroin in Halloween Candy

This is one of those myths that really grew into mass hysteria when in fact, it was an adult crime. In 1970 a five-year old went into a coma and died of a heroin overdose. Officials in Detroit had the candy analyzed but found out the real story.

Apparently, the five-year-old found his uncle's heroin stash and to prevent the uncle from doing jail time, the family sprinkled the heroin on the child's candy to protect the uncle. Most parents are responsible and loving, unlike these parents, so if you suspect your child has ingested any illegal drug, head to a pediatric urgent care center to get immediate treatment to avoid overdoses.

3. Candy Poisoning

Another myth behind Halloween candy comes from Vancouver. The Chicago Tribune also debunked this myth. Apparently a four-year-old became sick and died just one day after eating her trick or treat candy. In fear of tainted candy, law enforcement urged parents in Vancouver to get rid of all their children's candy and most did.

It was found later the child had suffered from a non-contagious Streptococcus bacteria. Streptococcus bacteria can be contagious and may present in the form of strep throat or impetigo. This Halloween scare was not actually a threat, but if your child complains of a bad sore throat or a rash develops at any time you should seek family care from a professional.

4. Needles Found in Candy Bar

With the myths out there about Halloween candy, there are also some facts. One is the case of James J. Smith of Minneapolis who inserted needles into Snickers candy bars and subsequently gave them out as treats. Although no child required medical attention one child did receive a small prick while eating the needle-laced candy.

James J. Smith was arrested and charged with "one count of adulterating a substance with intent to cause death, harm or illness," said The Chicago Tribune. One way to avoid scares like these is to check all of your child's candy before giving the okay to eat it.

5. Razor Blades in Apples

If you're a baby boomer, you probably heard the story about villains putting razor blades in apples and then giving handing them out at Halloween. This scare was first reported in the mid-1960s. Subsequently in 1968, author Jack Santino published a book "Halloween and Other Festivals of Death and Life" where he penned that a New Jersey law was passed that mandated "prison terms for people who booby-trapped apples." The year the book was published only 13 apples were found with razor blades inside and almost all other cases were discovered to be hoaxes.

Halloween is fun time for the entire family. It's easy to make sure your child's candy is safe by examination and to rid of any candy you're unsure about. Above all, if your child experiences any type of reaction after eating candy, seek an urgent care center.

FAQs

Was there ever strychnine found in Sunkist treats?

No, what was initially thought to be strychnine was actually cornstarch.

Was heroin ever found in Halloween candy?

No, the story of heroin in Halloween candy was a cover-up for a family crime.

Was there ever a case of Halloween candy causing a child's death due to poisoning?

No, the reported case was due to a non-contagious bacteria, not candy.

Have there been cases of harmful objects found in Halloween candy?

Yes, there have been isolated incidents, such as needles found in Snickers bars, but these are not common.

Were there ever razor blades found in apples given out on Halloween?

While there were reports in the 1960s, the majority of these cases were found to be hoaxes.

What should parents do if they find an unknown substance on their child's candy?

Do not let the child ingest the candy. If the child has already consumed it, it's advisable to head to an urgent care center to ensure the child's safety.

What should parents do if they suspect their child has ingested an illegal drug?

They should immediately take the child to a pediatric urgent care center to get immediate treatment and avoid overdoses.

What can parents do to avoid scares related to Halloween candies?

Parents can check all of their child's candy before giving the okay to eat it. Any candy that they are unsure about should be discarded.

Dr. Rob Rohatsch, MD, is a Board-Certified Emergency Medicine physician and urgent care executive. He earned his MD from Jefferson Medical College, currently serves on multiple boards and is Solv’s Chief Medical Officer.

How we reviewed this article

Medically reviewed

View this article’s sources and history, and read more about Solv’s Content Mission Statement, editorial process, and editorial team.

History

Solv’s team of medical writers and experts review and update our articles when new information becomes available.

  • October 14 2013

    Written by Solv Editorial Team

    Medically reviewed by: Dr. Rob Rohatsch, MD

Solv’s team of medical writers and experts review and update our articles when new information becomes available.

  • October 14 2013

    Written by Solv Editorial Team

    Medically reviewed by: Dr. Rob Rohatsch, MD

Topics in this article

Pediatric CareIllnessFamiliesEmergency CareHolidaysFirst AidMental HealthPreventionUrgent Care

This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using Solv, you accept our use of cookies.